Nov 15, 2026
Marcel Schmelzer Questions Ballon d’Or Politics After Kane Win
Former Borussia Dortmund captain Marcel Schmelzer has welcomed Harry Kane’s Ballon d’Or triumph as a positive moment for the Bundesliga, while also questioning the politics he believes can influence football’s biggest individual award. Schmelzer said Kane’s success matters for the league’s global standing, particularly as it ends a long wait for a Bundesliga-based winner.
Kane became the first player based in Germany’s top flight to win the prize since Matthias Sammer in 1996, according to the interview. Although Kane plays for Bayern Munich, Dortmund’s major domestic rival, Schmelzer set that rivalry aside to praise the significance of the award. He said he was pleased that Kane won this year rather than seeing Lionel Messi or Cristiano Ronaldo receive the honour again.
Schmelzer raises concerns over award voting
Schmelzer said he is not a major supporter of the Ballon d’Or format because the prize relies on votes. In his view, players themselves would offer the most accurate assessment of the game’s leading performers because they face each other on the pitch.
He pointed to Franck Ribéry, Wesley Sneijder and Robert Lewandowski as players he believes would have won in previous years if footballers had been responsible for the voting. Ribéry and Lewandowski were Bundesliga players at the time referenced by Schmelzer, reinforcing his view that elite performances in Germany have not always been fully recognised.
For Schmelzer, the award should be judged on performance across a single year rather than a player’s broader reputation or legacy. That perspective framed his approval of Kane’s victory: while he expressed reservations about the process, he regarded the result as a welcome acknowledgement for both the striker and the Bundesliga.
The former Germany international also addressed the larger challenge facing Dortmund as they attempt to compete with Bayern over a full league campaign. Schmelzer was part of Dortmund’s Bundesliga-winning sides in 2011 and 2012 under Jürgen Klopp, and he said the essential difference between challenging Bayern and finishing ahead of them is relentless consistency.
He argued that teams cannot reserve their sharpest focus for the biggest occasions. A side may be highly motivated after a Champions League match against Real Madrid, he said, but dropping intensity for a league trip to a smaller club can quickly create problems. Those opponents have often spent a full week preparing for the fixture, and even a small collective drop in performance can be costly.
Schmelzer said Bayern’s long-term strength has been their ability to win regardless of the opponent or whether they were the better side on a particular day. In his view, collecting points is ultimately more important than debating whether every victory was deserved, because the final table does not measure performances in isolation.
Dortmund’s balance of youth and experience
On Dortmund’s youth-focused approach, Schmelzer said the club can develop young players and still compete for the Bundesliga title, but only with patience and a carefully balanced squad. He said the club has publicly committed to developing talent rather than regularly buying expensive players from elsewhere, a route he described as difficult but potentially successful if the hierarchy and supporters remain committed.
He stressed that young talent alone is not enough to challenge Bayern. Schmelzer said a title contender needs experienced, high-quality figures alongside emerging players, rather than relying on an entire side of 18-year-olds. He sees the current direction as promising and said Dortmund are mounting a stronger challenge than in recent years.
Looking back at his own title-winning Dortmund teams, Schmelzer highlighted the influence of experienced leaders including Sebastian Kehl and Roman Weidenfeller. He said those players helped younger teammates deal with pressure, while a group of hungry players aged 19 to 21 brought energy to the squad. He also credited Klopp’s coaching staff and the unity of the group.
In a rapid-fire answer, Schmelzer named Felix Nmecha as the current Dortmund player who excites him most. He also predicted that Dortmund will next win the Bundesliga in 2029, offering a long-term marker for the club’s ambition to turn promising development into major silverware.


